Kelsey Mays

Owners of the new
cars reviewed by this
critic give him/her
an overall credibility
rating of:

8.5 out of 10
Critic's Review History

In their published
reviews, this critic awards
an average score of:

78

The highest score
awarded by this critic is:

88

The lowest score
awarded by this critic is:

49

2009 Porsche 911

09/14/09
88
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2009 Porsche 911
Coupe

Competitors from Mercedes and Jaguar may have more room, comfort and ride quality but none of them perform near the Porsche 911’s threshold.

2009 Infiniti G

05/21/09
87
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2009 Infiniti G
Coupe

Infiniti’s 2009 G37 coupe continues to impress. Stylish, quick and relatively affordable, it’s a compelling alternative to BMW’s 335i, with no excuses required.

2009 BMW Z4

08/14/09
87
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2009 BMW Z4
Convertible

The 2009 BMW Z4 occupies a sweet spot between performance and comfort. Surprisingly livable for every day, the Z4 is definitely worth checking out.

2009 Subaru Forester

12/31/09
87
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2009 Subaru Forester
SUV/Truck

Perhaps Subaru’s last hurdle is the Forester’s image as a quirky car for quirky people. The latest model does a lot to overcome this, and it’s time mainstream shoppers gave it a look.

2010 Audi A5

11/17/09
86
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Audi A5
Convertible
The Audi A5’s soft-top could keep some shoppers away, but the car’s versatility, style and relative fuel efficiency should draw more than a few of them back.

2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid

05/29/09
86
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid
Sedan

The Fusion Hybrid is a significant step forward for the technology, particularly for family sedans. It’s worth a look, and not just if you’re in the market for a hybrid or a Fusion.

2010 Chevrolet Camaro

03/20/09
86
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Chevrolet Camaro
Coupe

The Camaro SS is quick. Silly quick. But sadly, other aspects of the SS fail to impress. The more refined 305HP V-6 is expected to account for two-thirds of sales.

2010 Volkswagen GTI

01/29/10
86
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Volkswagen GTI
Hatchback

The 2010 Volkswagen GTI looks rakish but not rowdy; it prefers balance to sheer power. The kids will prefer a Mazdaspeed3 or Subaru WRX, but the GTI will keep its fans

2010 Audi S5

01/25/10
84
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Audi S5
Convertible

Sharp styling, unlikely versatility and a snappy drivetrain give the Audi S5 a fighting chance, despite the absence of a retractable hardtop. In an economy most would characterize as dubious, though, I wish the car wasn’t so doggone expensive.

2010 Chevrolet Traverse

12/30/09
84
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Chevrolet Traverse
SUV/Truck

GM gets points for making a styling statement, inside and out. I’ll harp about certain angles, but on the whole the Traverse at least looks interesting, and that’s ever so important in a field of increasingly similar-looking family-haulers.

2009 Mazda CX-7

12/08/08
84
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2009 Mazda CX-7
SUV/Truck

The Mazda CX-7 is not a particularly logical choice — but is it ever a fun one. Take a drive and consider some of the CX-7’s strengths that are less apparent on paper.

2010 Buick Enclave

05/25/10
84
100

Overall score awarded to vehicle by this critic. [?]

Reviewed By Critic Credibility [?] Style Reviewed
Kelsey Mays Kelsey Mays 8.5 out of 10 2010 Buick Enclave
SUV/Truck

The Enclave combines outstanding utility with premium touches not usually found in such a roomy vehicle. It’s styling and cabin design will impress less as fresh competition arrives, but I suspect the Enclave’s inherent qualities will be harder to beat.

MotorMouths Newsletter

Get the latest reviews,
buying advice, deals &
more. Sent once a month.